For decades, college has been presented as the conventional path to a successful career. Finish high school, attend a university, earn a degree, and use that degree to secure a good-paying job. For many professions, that path makes perfect sense. For others, however, it’s worth questioning whether the investment is really necessary.
Software engineering is one of those fields.
Unlike professions such as medicine or law, where formal education, professional qualifications, and licensing requirements are fundamental to entering the profession, software development is largely a skills-based industry. What matters most is whether you can solve problems, understand complex systems, write reliable code, and build software that works.
Yet students are routinely encouraged to spend tens of thousands of dollars, sometimes considerably more, pursuing degrees in computer science or software engineering. The assumption is that a degree will give them the knowledge and credentials necessary to enter the industry.
I’m not convinced that assumption holds up as well as people would like to believe.
The Difference Between Learning and Earning a Degree
I have been programming computers since approximately 1995. For much of that time, I was entirely self-taught, learning through experimentation, personal projects, reading documentation, and solving problems that interested me.
Years later, I returned to the formal education system, spending approximately twelve years in technical colleges and universities before earning a master’s degree in software engineering.
Having experienced both sides, I can honestly say that I learned more about programming through independent study and personal projects than I did in many of my college courses.
That isn’t to say I learned nothing in college. There were valuable courses, worthwhile discussions, and concepts that helped broaden my understanding of the discipline. However, there is a substantial difference between learning something because you need it to solve a real problem and learning something because it happens to be listed in a course syllabus.
When you’re working on your own software projects, you have a reason to learn. You encounter a problem, research possible solutions, evaluate different approaches, make mistakes, and eventually figure out what works. That process develops practical skills that are difficult to replicate in a classroom.
College, on the other hand, often places greater emphasis on completing assignments, meeting deadlines, and demonstrating that you’ve learned the material presented in a course. Those things have their place, but successfully completing an assignment doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve developed the skills needed to work as a software engineer.
The Problem With Outdated Curriculums
One of my biggest frustrations with formal education was the relevance of some of the material being taught.
Technology moves incredibly quickly. Programming languages, frameworks, development environments, and industry practices evolve constantly. Something that was considered relevant when a curriculum was developed might be outdated by the time a student graduates.
I remember taking a course that taught COBOL. There’s nothing inherently wrong with learning COBOL. It remains relevant in certain industries, particularly organizations maintaining older financial and government systems.
The problem was that the college couldn’t even provide us with a working compiler.
We were essentially writing programs and pretending they worked because we had no practical way to compile and execute them. Think about that for a moment. We were paying for an education in programming, but the institution couldn’t provide the basic tools necessary to practice what we were learning.
That experience illustrates a larger problem with some educational programs: the curriculum and the practical realities of software development aren’t always aligned.
A degree program should teach fundamental concepts that remain relevant regardless of which programming languages or technologies become popular. Problem-solving, algorithms, data structures, software architecture, debugging, and understanding how computers work are all valuable subjects.
However, there’s a difference between teaching foundational knowledge and spending an entire semester learning technologies that have little relevance to the student’s intended career.
Students shouldn’t have to choose between getting an education and developing the practical skills employers actually want.
Is the Name on Your Diploma Worth the Price?
Not all colleges provide the same educational experience, resources, or professional opportunities.
Attending a highly regarded institution such as Harvard or MIT can offer advantages that extend beyond the classroom. These universities have established reputations, extensive alumni networks, relationships with major employers, and opportunities to connect with people who can influence your career.
Those connections have value.
But what happens when you’re paying a substantial amount of money to attend a less-established institution, particularly an online university, without receiving comparable access to industry connections, recruiting opportunities, or professional networks?
I’m not suggesting that every online university provides a poor education. There are legitimate programs that offer flexibility and quality instruction. Nor does attending a prestigious university automatically make someone a better engineer.
The question is whether the educational experience and career opportunities justify the financial investment.
If you’re going to spend $40,000, $60,000, or even $100,000 pursuing a software engineering degree, you should have a reasonable expectation that the investment will provide meaningful benefits.
Simply receiving a diploma isn’t necessarily enough.
Getting Hired Is a Different Problem Entirely
Perhaps the biggest issue facing prospective software engineers today isn’t learning how to program. It’s getting someone to give them an opportunity.
The software engineering job market has become increasingly competitive. Employers receive enormous numbers of applications, entry-level positions can attract experienced applicants, and even candidates with advanced degrees can struggle to find employment.
A master’s degree doesn’t guarantee an interview, much less a job.
There’s also an uncomfortable reality about professional networking: knowing someone inside an organization can sometimes give you a substantially better opportunity than having a more impressive educational background.
A personal referral can help get your résumé noticed, get you past an initial screening, or put you in direct contact with someone responsible for hiring.
Meanwhile, someone with a master’s degree, an excellent academic record, and no professional connections may find their application buried among hundreds of others.
This isn’t necessarily a reflection of that person’s abilities. It’s a reflection of how hiring often works.
Employers want to reduce the risk of hiring someone who isn’t a good fit. A recommendation from a trusted employee can provide a level of confidence that a résumé or diploma alone cannot.
This creates an interesting contradiction: students are encouraged to invest heavily in education to improve their employment prospects, but the relationships they develop along the way may ultimately matter just as much, if not more.
The Alternative: Learn by Building
One of the advantages of software engineering is that you don’t necessarily need permission from an educational institution to start learning.
You can download development tools, access official documentation, take online courses, read technical books, and begin building software without spending thousands of dollars on tuition.
More importantly, you can build things that demonstrate your abilities.
A collection of completed projects can demonstrate that you understand programming concepts, can work through difficult problems, and know how to turn an idea into functioning software.
You can experiment with different languages, explore databases, learn about software architecture, work with APIs, and develop applications that solve actual problems.
You also have the freedom to learn at your own pace and concentrate on technologies that interest you or are relevant to the kind of work you want to pursue.
This approach requires discipline. Nobody is going to establish your deadlines, assign your coursework, or make sure you understand the material. You have to take responsibility for your own education.
But that is also part of becoming a good software engineer. The ability to independently research unfamiliar technologies, understand documentation, and learn new concepts is something you’ll need throughout your career.
Technology doesn’t stop changing when you graduate.
So, Is College Worth It?
I don’t believe there’s a universal answer. College can absolutely be worthwhile, particularly for someone who benefits from structured instruction, wants a strong theoretical foundation, or has access to a university with excellent industry connections and recruiting opportunities.
A degree can also help satisfy employer screening requirements, especially for candidates entering the industry without professional experience.
But I think prospective students should approach the decision much more critically than they often do.
Before committing to an expensive degree program, consider what you’re actually purchasing. Look beyond the marketing material and ask about the curriculum, instructors, practical experience, industry relationships, internship opportunities, graduate employment outcomes, and total cost.
Consider whether the same knowledge could be acquired through a combination of independent study, technical books, online courses, and personal projects.
And perhaps most importantly, consider whether the degree will meaningfully improve your chances of getting the job you’re pursuing.
I spent years programming as a hobbyist before returning to college, and I ultimately earned a master’s degree in software engineering. Having experienced both worlds, I wouldn’t automatically recommend that someone follow the same educational path.
If I were advising someone interested in software engineering today, I’d encourage them to start programming, build projects, develop a strong understanding of computer science fundamentals, and explore the industry before committing to an expensive degree.
College is one possible route into software engineering. It isn’t the only route, and it certainly isn’t a guarantee of success.
The goal should be to become a good software engineer, not simply to become someone with a software engineering degree.
What are your thoughts? What is your experience with formal and self-taught education?
Leave a Reply