Chasing Clout

One thing I’ve become increasingly tired of seeing on the internet is people recording themselves doing supposedly generous things for other people, only to upload the videos to social media for attention, subscribers, and financial gain.

You’ll see videos of someone buying groceries for a homeless person, handing out food, giving someone money, paying to repair a stranger’s car, or buying necessities for a family struggling to make ends meet. On the surface, these appear to be wonderful acts of kindness. And perhaps the people involved really are helping someone.

But then you look a little closer.

There’s a camera recording the entire interaction. There’s someone narrating what’s happening. There’s an exaggerated thumbnail, a carefully crafted title about how generous the creator is, and eventually a monetized video filled with advertisements.

At some point, you have to ask yourself: Is this really about helping someone, or is it about creating content?

Someone who genuinely wants to do something nice for another person doesn’t need to turn the entire experience into a production. If you want to buy a homeless person a meal, buy them a meal. If you want to help someone repair their car, help them repair their car. You don’t need a camera crew, a YouTube channel, or thousands of strangers watching to make that act meaningful.

And you certainly don’t need to upload the experience to the internet so you can profit from it.

Think about the person on the receiving end of these interactions. Imagine being homeless, struggling to afford food, or going through one of the most difficult periods of your life. Someone approaches you offering assistance, but there’s a camera pointed directly at your face. Your hardship, your appearance, your personal circumstances, and potentially your most vulnerable moments are now being broadcast to thousands or millions of strangers.

All so someone else can collect views, subscribers, advertising revenue, and praise in the comments section.

What makes this particularly uncomfortable is the imbalance between the person filming and the person being filmed. The creator gets the financial benefits, the publicity, and the reputation of being a wonderful human being. The person receiving help gets a meal or some money, but also potentially loses their privacy and dignity in the process.

And let’s not pretend the titles are accidental.

“Incredibly Generous Man Feeds 100 Homeless People!”

“Struggling Mother Breaks Down After Stranger Buys Her Groceries!”

“Man Repairs Stranger’s Car for FREE!”

These titles aren’t simply documenting charitable acts. They’re selling an emotional experience to an audience. The people receiving help become the subject matter, while the person providing it becomes the star of the show.

There’s something particularly ironic about making money from a video featuring someone who is struggling financially. The creator might spend $100 buying groceries for someone, but then upload a video that generates advertising revenue, attracts new subscribers, and potentially earns them considerably more than they spent.

In other words, someone else’s hardship has become a business opportunity.

And Then There’s the Audience

Perhaps what frustrates me almost as much as the videos themselves is the reaction from the general public.

Go into the comments section of one of these videos and you’ll find hundreds of people praising the creator.

“God bless this man!”

“You’re an angel!”

“This world needs more people like you!”

“He’s going places!”

“Thank you for being such an amazing human being!”

And apparently, nobody stops to think about what they’re actually watching.

Does it ever occur to anyone that perhaps this person isn’t doing all of this simply out of the goodness of their heart? That maybe the reason they’re recording every interaction, publishing carefully edited videos, creating emotionally manipulative thumbnails, and monetizing the entire experience is because they’re trying to build an audience and make money?

Seriously, how difficult is it to recognize what’s happening?

These creators have figured out that generosity is incredibly marketable. They know that showing themselves helping disadvantaged people generates positive reactions, emotional engagement, subscribers, and views. They know exactly what kind of content makes people feel good, and they’ve turned it into a business model.

And the audience eats it up.

The creator gets thousands of comments telling them what a wonderful person they are, while the audience completely overlooks the fact that the person they’re praising is making money by broadcasting someone else’s unfortunate circumstances.

It’s almost comical. People are so eager to congratulate someone for being a good human being that they never stop to question whether the entire performance is genuine.

I’m not saying every person who records a charitable act is necessarily a bad person. But if you’re going to publicly broadcast your generosity, monetize it, and use it to build your personal brand, don’t be surprised when I question your motives.

And to everyone flooding those comment sections with praise, perhaps spend a little less time congratulating these people and a little more time thinking critically about what you’re watching.

There’s a Difference Between Helping and Performing

Now, I understand that there are arguments in favor of these videos. Some people will say that recording charitable acts inspires others to help. Others will argue that the videos raise awareness or encourage donations. And those are legitimate points. Publicizing charitable work isn’t inherently wrong, and there are organizations that genuinely benefit from documenting what they do.

But there’s a difference between raising awareness for a cause and turning an individual’s suffering into entertainment.

There’s also a difference between encouraging generosity and constantly reminding everyone how generous you are.

I don’t need to see someone hand a homeless person a sandwich and then spend the next ten minutes explaining what a wonderful person they are. I don’t need a dramatic soundtrack, a slow-motion reaction shot, or a thumbnail showing someone crying. And I certainly don’t need advertisements running throughout a video that exists because someone else is struggling to survive.

If you genuinely want to help someone, help them. Do it because another human being needs assistance, not because you want strangers on the internet to congratulate you for doing it.

You don’t need an audience to be a decent human being.

And if your generosity requires a camera, a thumbnail, a monetized video, and thousands of people telling you how amazing you are, perhaps it’s worth reconsidering who you’re actually doing it for.

Sometimes the best thing you can do for another person is help them without making them part of your personal publicity campaign.

Comments

3 responses to “Chasing Clout”

  1. Leslie Lanagan Avatar
    Leslie Lanagan

    I absolutely agree, but as a creator on the other side of the issue, it’s a mixed bag. You want to reflect your real life, within limits. You have to have a personal footprint. You are allowed to have it- but I personally do not like performance, and my experience has not been that people gladhand at all. If anything, the moment you start having a unique voice, the moment there is a target on your back because the system rewards conformity…… so it is a balance.

  2. Kenneth R. Jones Avatar

    I feel like, if you want to do something nice for someone, and it is truly because you are a good person and doing it for the right reasons, you do not need to be recognized for the act.

    There are many people who are very rich and donate regularly (in one way or another) but we don’t know about them, because they don’t put their face out there for the world to clap for.

    If you can’t do the good deed anonymously, you may need to reevaluate your reasons for doing it at all. Some people just need to stand at the podium.

  3. Leslie Lanagan Avatar

    That is exactly right. And I also think that there is a big difference between documenting something and trying to sell something.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.